The Formation of Offshore Bars and Barrier Islands
- Tom McAndrew
- 1 day ago
- 4 min read
Coastal landscapes are constantly reshaped by natural forces—waves roll in from the sea, currents shift sediments, and the shoreline responds in subtle and dramatic ways. Among the landforms that emerge from this interaction are offshore bars and barrier islands. Though they may seem alike at first glance, these features differ in how they form, how they behave, and what roles they play in coastal environments. Understanding their formation and characteristics offers valuable insights into coastal dynamics and the impact of rising sea levels.
Offshore Bars: Shifting Ridges Beneath the Waves
Offshore bars are ridges of sand or shingle lying parallel to the coast, either submerged or partially visible in the nearshore zone. They are highly dynamic features, constantly shifting with the rhythms of wave energy and sediment supply. The creation of offshore bars is closely tied to wave action. As waves approach the shore and begin to feel the seabed, they slow down and refract. This process, combined with the breaking of waves, stirs up seabed sediment and deposits it just offshore. Constructive waves, with their strong swash and weak backwash, encourage sediment accumulation that helps form these bars.
Storms also play a crucial role. Powerful waves generated during storm events erode material from beaches and deposit it offshore, building temporary bars that can later migrate back toward the shore under calmer conditions. Longshore drift adds another layer to this process, carrying sediment along the coast until energy drops and it’s deposited in bar formations. Offshore bars frequently develop near river mouths where sediment loads are high, creating fertile ground for deposition.
These bars come in several forms. Breakpoint bars arise where waves first break, while longshore bars develop parallel to the coast due to drifting sediment. Crescentic bars, often curved, form where wave refraction occurs around headlands. Along the Norfolk Coast, for example, offshore bars are a common feature, while Chesil Beach, primarily known as a barrier beach, also displays offshore bar activity in its surrounding waters.
Barrier Islands: Coastal Guardians Above the Tide
Barrier islands are a different story altogether. These long, narrow, sandy islands sit above sea level, separated from the mainland by lagoons or marshes. They're usually found along low-gradient coastlines such as the eastern seaboard of the United States. Unlike the relatively short-lived offshore bars, barrier islands are more permanent fixtures, and their formation has sparked multiple theories.
One early theory, proposed by De Beaumont in 1845, suggests that barrier islands begin as offshore bars that rise above sea level through sediment accumulation. As vegetation takes hold, the features become stabilised and develop dune systems. Another view, from Fisher in 1968, argues that longshore drift extends spits across coastal bays, which are then cut off by storm breaches, leaving standalone islands. The famous Hurst Castle Spit in the UK could become a barrier island if breached in this way.
The submergence theory, dating back to McGee in 1890, posits that rising sea levels flood pre-existing coastal dunes, isolating them as barrier islands. This likely explains the origin of many islands along the Atlantic coast of the USA, particularly during the Holocene period. A final model suggests that as beach ridges build outward, storm surges separate them, leaving behind a chain of islands.
Barrier islands typically feature wind-blown dunes stabilised by vegetation like marram grass, and the lagoons and marshes behind them often support vibrant ecosystems. Storm breaches can create tidal inlets—natural channels that allow water and sediment exchange between the sea and the back-barrier environment. Notable examples include the Outer Banks in North Carolina and the barrier island chains of the Wadden Sea shared by the Netherlands, Germany, and Denmark.
How Do They Compare?
To understand how offshore bars and barrier islands differ, it helps to lay out their characteristics side by side:
Feature | Offshore Bars | Barrier Islands |
Position | Submerged or partially exposed | Fully exposed above sea level |
Formation | Wave deposition, storm activity | Multiple theories (spits, drowned dunes, etc.) |
Stability | Temporary, shift with waves | More permanent, stabilised by vegetation |
Size | Smaller, narrow ridges | Larger, can be tens of kilometers long |
Separation from Mainland | Close to shore, within the nearshore zone | Separated by lagoons or marshes |
Sediment Source | Marine erosion, longshore drift | Fluvial and marine sources |
Human Impact | Less likely to be inhabited | Often developed (e.g., Miami Beach) |
The distinctions are striking. Offshore bars are usually underwater and highly mobile, while barrier islands are large, above sea level, and often support both natural habitats and human activity. Their formation processes also vary significantly in complexity and timescale.
Sea-Level Change: The Great Shaper
Both offshore bars and barrier islands respond dynamically to sea-level change. When sea levels rise—as in the submergence theory—dunes may become isolated as barrier islands. Falling sea levels, on the other hand, can expose submerged offshore bars, potentially transforming them into beaches or the early stages of barrier islands. Whether through long-term transgressions or more localised shifts, sea level is a major force in shaping these coastal features.
Human and Environmental Impacts
From a human perspective, both landforms play critical roles in coastal systems. Barrier islands are natural buffers, absorbing wave energy and protecting the mainland during storms. The sheltered lagoons and marshes behind them serve as rich habitats for wildlife. However, many barrier islands—like those along Florida’s coast—are heavily developed, which increases the risk of erosion and storm damage.
Offshore bars, while less visible and less likely to host human infrastructure, still affect surf conditions, influence sediment transport, and can be a hazard or help to navigation depending on their location and size.
To summarise....
Though born of similar marine forces, offshore bars and barrier islands represent different stages and scales of coastal evolution. Bars are transient, mobile features driven by short-term wave action, while barrier islands are larger, more stable landforms that evolve over centuries in response to broader environmental changes.
Further Reading & References
Bird, E. (2008) Coastal Geomorphology: An Introduction. Wiley.
Davis, R.A. & Fitzgerald, D.M. (2004) Beaches and Coasts. Blackwell.
Masselink, G. & Hughes, M. (2003) Introduction to Coastal Processes and Geomorphology. Hodder Education.
Commentaires